Filter by:

Clear All
Min: $3.00 Max: $28.00
$3 $28

Spreads & Butters

Sort By
Page Size

Juice Sweetened Pumpkin Butter - 19...

Smooth pumpkin butter spread that is almost as if spreading pumpkin pie onto your favorite food! Same great taste as the pumpkin butter but sweetened with juice instead of sugar! Have a taste of the McCutcheon Apple Product's that is made in Fredrick, Maryland here in the USA.
$3.95
McCutcheon Apple Products
Frederick, MD

All-Natural Creamy Peanut Butter - ...

Crazy Richard's 16 oz. Natural Creamy Peanut Butter
$3.99
Crazy Richard's Peanut Butter Company
Dublin, OH

Original Tiger Butter - 14 oz.

Original 14 oz Tiger Butter The Original Tiger Butter is a naturally sweet and nutty treat without the nuts or added sugar. If you like peanut butter or almond butter, but want a more nutrient dense option or if you have an allergy Original Tiger Butter is a must have!
$16.99
Tiger Butter
Hilton Head Island, SC

Pumpkin Butter - 18 oz.

McCutcheon's Apple Products Pumpkin Butter is a blend of pumpkin and spices - basically everything you love in pumpkin pie, but without the crust! Whether you use Pumpkin Butter by itself or mixed within a recipe, it makes everything delicious! Take a taste of Fredrick, Maryland that is here in the USA where McCutcheon's Apples is made!
$3.50
McCutcheon Apple Products
Frederick, MD

All-Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter -...

Crazy Richard's 16oz 100% Peanuts all-natural Crunchy Peanut Butter
$3.99
Crazy Richard's Peanut Butter Company
Dublin, OH

Almond Butter - 16 oz.

Crazy Richard's 16oz - Almond Butter
$9.50
Crazy Richard's Peanut Butter Company
Dublin, OH

Cashew Butter - 11 oz.

Crazy Richard's 11oz Cashew Butter
$9.50
Crazy Richard's Peanut Butter Company
Dublin, OH

100% Pure All Natural Peanut Powder...

Crazy Richard's 6.5oz 100% Pure All Natural Peanut Powder 100% – Peanuts, Peanut Powder is a whole family product that can be used in smoothies, baking and cooking!
$3.99
Crazy Richard's Peanut Butter Company
Dublin, OH

100% Pure Peanut Powder - 2 lbs.

Crazy Richard's 2 lbs. 100% Pure Peanut Powder
$18.99
Crazy Richard's Peanut Butter Company
Dublin, OH

Apple Butter - 4 oz.

This smooth, creamy, spread is made with fresh local organic apples, apple cider, honey, and blend of spices.
$10.00
Bushwick Sauce Company
Ridgewood, NY

Strawberry Jam - 4 oz.

This jam is made with fresh local organic strawberries, pure cane sugar, and lemon juice. That's it. No added pectin or artificial preservatives. Made the old fashioned way, pure and simple.
$10.00
Bushwick Sauce Company
Ridgewood, NY

Hot & Sweet Mustard - 4 Jars

This is a classic, award winning mustard. Hand prepared in Northern California since 1977, the unique flavor of Hot & Sweet will make it one of the versatile condiments in your kitchen.
$27.95
Mendocino Foods, Inc.
Mendocino, CA

Seeds & Suds Mustard - 4 Jars

Brown and yellow mustard seeds combine with RED SEAL ALE to produce this gold medal winner. Seeds & Suds has been a word of mouth favorite since we began hand preparing it in 1996.
$27.95
Mendocino Foods, Inc.
Mendocino, CA

Blueberry Lemon Basil Jam - 9 oz.

Sweet and herbaceous.
$13.99
Trade Street Jam Co.
Brooklyn, NY

Chinese 5 Spiced Apple Butter - 9 oz.

Warm and spiced.
$13.99
Trade Street Jam Co.
Brooklyn, NY

Plum & Rose Jam - 9 oz.

Floral and tart.
$13.99
Trade Street Jam Co.
Brooklyn, NY

Smoked Peach Jam - 9 oz.

Sweet & smoky, like summer grilling in a jar.
$13.99
Trade Street Jam Co.
Brooklyn, NY

Apple Butter - 8 oz.

Delicious blend of apples and spices!
$9.00
Blue Owl Preserves
Colorado Springs, CO

Apricot Low Sugar Fruit Spread - 8 oz.

Tart and summery jam!
$9.00
Blue Owl Preserves
Colorado Springs, CO

Blueberry Rhubarb Low Sugar Fruit S...

Like strawberry rhubarb pie, but better!
$9.00
Blue Owl Preserves
Colorado Springs, CO